Remember the days before email when getting the mail was actually a big deal? Especially for kids (who didn’t have to worry about the bills their parents hated to get), seeing your name on an envelope meant something…especially when it was eagerly expected.
VH1 attempted to recreate that emotion last week with a contest they ran. The idea? Data collection, of course. They drove to sign up people for their VH1 Classic list by offering the chance to win either a Genesis or Led Zeppelin box set.
After signing up, the user was prompted to check their email on Friday at 1 pm EST for details on how they could win. It wasn’t enough to get me intrigued to sign up (VH1 has nine different newsletters), but VH1 did take a different route as opposed to the normal sign up/prizes drawn at random approach many take.
Having said that, a few logistical thoughts came up:
-Why? I guess I don’t understand why they would drive to have users check their email at a certain time and not the actual website.
-As any ESP will tell you, guaranteeing emails to all arrive at a certain time can be difficult. If an ISP throws a curveball or there are traditional issues with email transit, some people may not get it exactly at 1 pm. As a result, the reasoning behind having people check their inbox is moot.
-I understand that people can access email everywhere, but would you remember to check your inbox at a certain time for something like this? Yeah, I probably wouldn’t either and it’s doubtful I’d set a calendar reminder. Again, VH1 was simply providing how you could win the set, not if you actually won.
I appreciate what they were trying to do, but I’d remind the network that building a separate list of opt-in users from their other lists was the key. The best way to do that? Show value*. Provide an easy incentive to sign up. Make it truly different than the eight other newsletters you churn out.
*The word ‘value’ is the most undeveloped point of importance with marketers today, in my opinion. I think we need to ask ourselves in everything we do if it provides value to the end user. Whether it’s a blog post or a brochure or a phone call, are we providing value or are we carelessly running through the motions?